Skip to main content

The making of a “liberator” brand


Routine is good, difference is bad. Happiness is eating the same breakfast every day. Welcome the “Routine Republic”, a fictional communist state ad produced by Taco Bell to reframe McDonald’s as an oppressive breakfast regime. Has Taco Bell gone too far? And most importantly, is it going to work?
The reality is that McDonald’s is a big corporation that commands the lion’s share of breakfast fast food category at 30% US market share. McDonald’s has a reputation for serving cheap and unhealthy food. And in some areas of the country, it might be the only affordable option for a meal.
Whether any of us enjoys a good McMuffin or not, this has all the ingredients for the making of a fictional “communist country”, a state-run monopoly that provides few options and low living standard to its citizens. Therefore, people are living in a state of compliance “routine” and need to defy the establishment to change their lives.
This sounds pretty close to the oppressive states in The Hunger Games orDivergent to me. To Taco Bell’s credit, there is method to its madness. Habits are hard to break. You need to get a person out of their stable mindset in order to make them open to new information. This technique is called “Disrupt & Reframe” in advertising.
Reframing McDonald’s as a communist state is trying to achieve that. Today, McDonald’s is a cultural code for America and by extension, for freedom and individual expression, which is the antithesis of a dictatorship. This opens the door to persuade people to defy their breakfast routine, McDonald’s, to find true individual expression in another option: Taco Bell.
The challenge is that things get too weird with the oppressive clown dictator to the point that I don't feel good about the ad. As a father of a three year old, I go every weekend to McDonald’s. My kid loves the toy in the happy meal and I take comfort that the french fries are balanced by apple slices and milk. The ad almost feels like a personal criticism. People tend to align their actions with their emotions. As a result, I believe this ad is more likely to disgust than to persuade people to change their breakfast routine.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Curse of Advertising Resources

With more platforms, more products and more content who are trying to reach a disengaged audience, it is becoming harder and harder for brands to stand out. Conventional practices are no longer working. People don't watch TV as much as they used to, so they don't see commercials.  They don't click on banner ads. They don't pay attention to billboards ads. And they don't trust brands' messages. Part of the problem is that we are too dependent on traditional ad resources, which limits the realm of our creativity. To thrive in this new environment, we, ironically, need the freedom of a tight brief: what can you do with no budget for mass media?  Or limited marketing communications dollars?  To make a comparison, traditional advertising is a lot like countries and economies that rely on oil. This reliance handicaps innovation. Countries with a vast amount of natural resources tend to have (1) less economic growth and (2) worse development rates than other countrie…

The Irrational Power of Nudge Brands

Nudge brands are brands built on interactions, not attitudes. They are mostly defined by experiences, not TV campaigns. They are designed around people's inconsistencies and errors, not for machines. They are simple, not complex. They like to break things into small chunks that are less daunting than big tasks. They focus on changing behavior, not generating awareness and interest. The Paris metro system card is a nudge brand. It is designed against human errors. You can use the card in any direction. IKEA is a nudge brand. It uses the power of personal investment. The more involved people are in creating something, the better they feel about the end product. Ryanair is a nudge brand. It chunks the whole purchase process. They lock you in with a low 'seat price' first to get a mental commitment. Then, they start to add the extra charges in bite-sized 'chunks.' Hare Krishna is a nudge brand. It is built on the reciprocity rule by giving away daisies. People should …

The Irrational Challenger

Today, irrational is the new normal. People want products and services that break conventions and defy social norms. They have expectations that don't fit the traditional business model and feel irrational. However, they are very real and have created an irrational economy with irrational challengers. To thrive in this new playing field, business needs to be human, irrational. Think about it. Having a concierge to run our weekly errands for $99 month. Alfred. Ordering a healthy and delicious meal ready-to-eat under 7 minutes delivered at your door the next day. Hungryroot. Booking unlimited blowout appointments at salons in Manhattan for just $99 a month. Vive. (A typical blowout cost $40 to $90 inNew York City.) Renting a room on a month-to-month basis without going through the traditional methods of verifying applicants (e.g., two years of tax returns as proof of income).